AI Blocks › Think it through and decide
Idea trial jury
Give it a plan or claim. Get a verdict from a prosecutor, a defender and 12 jurors, plus what would flip it.
Idea trial jury is a free AI skill for the job "Think it through and decide". Give the instructions to an AI assistant that supports the required files and tools, then review its output.
Free · No account · CC BY 4.0 licence · Made by sickn33 · Thinking: high
Made by sickn33. See the original on GitHub; we copied it as it is, with its licence.
What it does
A verdict on your plan, argued like a court case, for the times when Claude agrees with everything you say. A prosecutor builds the case against it, a defender builds the case for it and a jury of twelve independent Claudes votes without seeing each other. You play no part in the argument. The skill acts as clerk, keeps the record and never softens the result. A Python script handles the bookkeeping, with a quick mode and a juror count. You get the vote count, the reasons and what facts or changes would flip the verdict. It suits a plan, a purchase, a post, a code approach or a claim. It needs Python and the ability to run subagents.
You give it
- The idea, plan or claim
- Facts the court should know (optional)
- Number of jurors or quick mode (optional)
- Python on your computer
You get
- The case for and the case against
- A jury vote count with reasons
- A clear verdict
- What would flip the decision
Use it when
- You keep getting yes from AI and want a real challenge.
- You are deciding whether to make a big purchase or change.
- You want to know how a claim holds up before posting it.
- You need an outcome from many views, not one.
How to use it
- Add it to your AI once: download it and add the folder to Claude, ChatGPT or Codex as a skill.
- Ask for the job in your own words. Your AI opens the skill when it fits.
- It works best when your AI can run code and start helper agents.