AI Blocks › Think it through and decide
Idea debate judge
Give it an idea. Get a three-round debate between a fan and a critic, then a clear verdict.
Idea debate judge is a free AI skill for the job "Think it through and decide". Give the instructions to an AI assistant that supports the required files and tools, then review its output.
Free · No account · CC BY 4.0 licence · Made by sickn33 · Level: beginner
Made by sickn33. See the original on GitHub; we copied it as it is, with its licence.
What it does
A verdict on your idea after both sides have argued it. Give it a concept, feature or project and get a three-round debate between a supporter and a critic, then a judge's summary. In round one, the supporter makes the strongest case and the critic names the biggest risks. In round two, each answers the other's points. In round three, both give closing statements. The rules say neither side may simply agree or disagree; each must argue from logic, market facts and how hard it is to build. A neutral orchestrator then steps in as judge and writes a summary with the key arguments and a clear call on whether to go ahead, with what to watch.
You give it
- The idea in a few sentences
- Who it is for (optional)
- Constraints such as time or budget (optional)
You get
- A three-round debate transcript
- Strongest points for and against
- A judge's summary and verdict
Use it when
- You have a new idea and cannot tell if it is worth your time.
- You must choose between product features and want the best arguments for each.
- You want to test an assumption before you start building.
- Your own view is too one-sided and you need the other case.
How to use it
- Add it to your AI once: download it and add the folder to Claude, ChatGPT or Codex as a skill.
- Ask for the job in your own words. Your AI opens the skill when it fits.