AI Blocks › Teach and train people
AI answer critique activity builder
Give it a subject. Get a worksheet that has students judge an AI answer on clarity, evidence and fairness.
AI answer critique activity builder is a free AI skill for the job "Teach and train people". Give the instructions to an AI assistant that supports the required files and tools, then review its output.
Free · No account · CC BY SA 4.0 licence · Made by Gareth Manning
Made by Gareth Manning. See the original on GitHub; we copied it as it is, with its licence.
What it does
A class worksheet set that teaches students to read an AI answer closely instead of trusting how smooth it sounds. It is built around six standards for judging claims: clear, accurate, precise, relevant, deep and broad. People spot weak writing by clues like bad grammar or an odd source. AI text has none of those, so students need a new reading habit. The kit has a markup guide where students underline claims stated with too much confidence, numbers with no source and expert-sounding words with little behind them. A scoring grid rates each standard weak, medium or strong. It adds push-back sentence starters and a teacher script that models the first read aloud.
You give it
- Your subject and year level
- A topic or question for the AI to answer
- A sample AI answer (optional)
- Time available for the lesson (optional)
You get
- A markup guide for students
- A weak, medium, strong scoring grid
- Sentence starters for pushing back
- A teacher modelling script
Use it when
- Your students copy AI answers and never question them.
- You need a ready activity on judging AI text for your subject.
- You want students to give reasons for what they trust, not just opinions.
- You want a teacher script to show how a close read sounds.
How to use it
- Add it to your AI once: download it and add the folder to Claude, ChatGPT or Codex as a skill.
- Ask for the job in your own words. Your AI opens the skill when it fits.